Ontario insurance claims outlook, Q3 2026: what changed and our forecasts to mid-2027
Data period: Q3 2026 (July to September); Statistics Canada CPI through October 2026; FSRA approvals to 10 November 2026; Équité theft data to the first half of 2026; forecasts to June 2027

Ontario auto ends 2026 with prices flat and costs still rising. Statistics Canada's index for passenger vehicle insurance premiums in Ontario was unchanged in the year to October, after rising +8.3% the year before, while parts, maintenance and repairs rose +4.2% (adverse for insurers) [1]. Our forecasts keep that gap open through mid-2027: repair costs about +5% (adverse for insurers) a year, the premium index close to zero. On a typical book that is several points of loss ratio pressure, offset only in part by lower auto theft [4].
Two structural changes run alongside the numbers. The accident benefits reforms of 1 July 2026 made several benefits optional [3], and FSRA rate approvals since July have a median change of zero [2]. Every forecast below has a central number, an 80% range, the method and the source.
Key findings
- Executive
On an illustrative 70% book, repair costs rising +5.0% (adverse for insurers) against a premium index at -0.4% add almost 4 points (adverse for insurers) to the Ontario auto loss ratio by December 2026. Falling theft and the accident benefits reforms offset part of that, but not yet measurably.
- Claims
Ontario parts, maintenance and repair prices are forecast up +5.0% (adverse for insurers) in the year to December 2026 (80% range +4.3% to +6.0%), and vehicle purchase prices +2.6% (adverse for insurers).
- Underwriting
The Ontario premium index is forecast at -0.4% in December 2026, and FSRA approvals since July have a median of zero. Expect flat average pricing into mid-2027, with the residual market the exception at +8.7%.
- Claims
Auto theft fell 22% in Ontario in 2025 and 10.1% nationally in the first half of 2026, but fraud is moving to documents: synthetic identity finance fraud, re-VINing and fake pink slips.
What you can do about this
For executives
- 1
Personal auto
Set 2027 Ontario auto targets on a widening cost-price gap
Repair costs forecast at 5.0% (adverse for insurers) against a premium index at -0.4% move an illustrative 70% book to about 73.8% (adverse for insurers). Plan on that path unless your own frequency data shows a clear offset.
For claims teams
- 1
Personal auto
Automate repair estimate review against current rates
Repair inflation is forecast at 5.0% (adverse for insurers) to December. Flag estimates and supplements whose labour or parts rates run above your benchmarks.
- 2
Fraud
Check theft total losses against recovery and document evidence
Only 51% (adverse for insurers) of Ontario stolen vehicles were recovered in 2025, and finance fraud with synthetic identities is rising. Confirm recovery status, ownership and finance documents before payment.
For underwriters
- 1
Regulation
Record accident benefit selections as policies renew
Most Ontario policies will have renewed under the 1 July 2026 rules by mid-2027. Keep the coverage chosen and any written change on file for claims staff.
The forecasts in brief
Forecast | Central | 80% range | Method | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Passenger vehicle parts, maintenance and repairs CPI, Ontario, YoY Dec 2026 | +5.0% (adverse for insurers) | +4.3% to +6.0% | 12-month log trend, backtested | StatCan [1] |
Same, YoY Jun 2027 | +4.5% (adverse for insurers) | +2.7% to +6.7% | Same | StatCan [1] |
Passenger vehicle insurance premiums CPI, Ontario, YoY Dec 2026 | -0.4% | -2.0% to +1.0% | Same | StatCan [1] |
Same, YoY Jun 2027 | +1.0% | -3.7% to +5.6% | Same, wide errors | StatCan [1] |
Purchase of passenger vehicles CPI, Ontario, YoY Dec 2026 | +2.6% (adverse for insurers) | +1.0% to +4.2% | Same | StatCan [1] |
Homeowners' home and mortgage insurance CPI, Ontario, YoY Dec 2026 | +1.8% | +0.1% to +3.4% | Same | StatCan [1] |
All-items CPI, Ontario, YoY Dec 2026 | +3.1% | +2.4% to +4.0% | Same | StatCan [1] |
Want the next report when it comes out? We can email it to you.
Subscribe1. Ontario's quarter: flat premiums, rising repair bills
Measure | Latest | Period | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
Passenger vehicle insurance premiums CPI, Ontario | 0.0% | YoY Oct 2026 | StatCan [1] |
Passenger vehicle parts, maintenance and repairs CPI, Ontario | +4.2% (adverse for insurers) | YoY Oct 2026 | StatCan [1] |
Purchase of passenger vehicles CPI, Ontario | +2.2% (adverse for insurers) | YoY Oct 2026 | StatCan [1] |
FSRA auto rate approvals since 1 July 2026 | 21: 8 down, 7 unchanged, 6 up; median 0.0% | Approvals to 10 Nov 2026 | FSRA [2] |
Auto theft, Ontario | -22% (favorable for insurers) | 2025 vs 2024 | Équité [4] |
Auto theft, Canada | -10.1% (favorable for insurers) | H1 2026 vs H1 2025 | Équité [5] |
Stolen vehicle recovery rate, Ontario | 51% (adverse for insurers) | 2025 | Équité [4] |
In the third quarter itself the premium index rose +1.0% to +1.8% year on year, while repair costs rose +3.1% (adverse for insurers) [1]. By October the premium index had reached zero.
2. Where Ontario claim costs go next
2.1 Claim severity
Year-on-year change, actual to Oct 2026, then central forecast with 80% range to Jun 2027
Source: Statistics Canada Table 18-10-0004-01 (Ontario); Inaza forecast, as of November 18, 2026
Our central forecast has Ontario parts, maintenance and repair prices up +5.0% (adverse for insurers) in the year to December 2026 and +4.5% (adverse for insurers) by June 2027 [1]. Vehicle purchase prices, which set total loss settlements, are forecast at +2.6% (adverse for insurers) in December [1]. Statistics Canada updates the Ontario repair index less often than monthly, so it moves in steps; the range reflects that.
2.2 Premium and rate trend
Year-on-year change, actual to Oct 2026, then central forecast with 80% range to Jun 2027
Source: Statistics Canada Table 18-10-0004-01 (Ontario); Inaza forecast, as of November 18, 2026
The Ontario premium index is forecast at -0.4% in December 2026, with an 80% range of -2.0% to +1.0% [1]. FSRA's approvals support a flat reading: since July, decreases and increases roughly balance, and many take effect on renewals between December 2026 and March 2027 [2]. The residual market is the exception, with an approved +8.7% for the Facility Association from 6 November 2026 [2].
2.3 Theft and fraud
We do not forecast theft counts, because Équité publishes them twice a year and the series is too short for the backtested method. The direction is clear: thefts fell 22% in Ontario in 2025 and 10.1% nationally in the first half of 2026 [4][5]. The risk has moved to documents: vehicle finance fraud with synthetic identities, re-VINing and fake proof of insurance [4][6]. Expect fewer theft claims in 2027, with a higher share of them involving export, identity or document fraud.
2.4 Regulation with known dates
The 1 July 2026 accident benefits reforms apply as policies renew, so most Ontario policies will have passed through a renewal under the new rules by mid-2027 [3]. Medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits remain mandatory; income replacement, non-earner, caregiver and several other benefits are now optional coverages that must be offered [3].
Monthly reports and live alerts, by email, when you want them.
Subscribe3. Reform, rates and the 2027 margin
Personal auto
As an illustration only: a book running at a 70% loss ratio, whose claim costs rose in line with our December repair forecast (+5.0%) while its average premium moved in line with the premium index forecast (-0.4%), would move to about 73.8% (adverse for insurers), a rise of almost 4 points (adverse for insurers). Lower theft frequency and the accident benefits changes work in the other direction, but there is not yet enough public data to size them.
Commercial auto
The same repair pressure applies. FSRA's public approvals database covers private passenger auto only [2], so we have no public Ontario price measure for commercial auto in this edition.
Property
The homeowners' insurance index is forecast at +1.8% in December [1], against homeowners' maintenance and repairs at +1.3% in October [1]. That is the most balanced of the Ontario lines on the public price data.
Summary
Line | Cost path to mid-2027 | Price path | Loss ratio reading |
|---|---|---|---|
Personal auto | Repair +4.5% to +5.0% (adverse for insurers), vehicles +2.6% (adverse for insurers) | Premium index about zero | Rising unless frequency falls |
Commercial auto | Repair pressure as personal auto | No public measure | Moderate pressure |
Property | Maintenance and repairs +1.3% | Homeowners' insurance +1.8% | Broadly stable |
The point estimates come from our model or the official figures cited. The ratings are our judgment.
4. How the forecasts were built
- Forecasts. For each Statistics Canada series (table 18-10-0004-01, Ontario, not seasonally adjusted) we project the log index forward at the mean monthly log change over the 12 months to October 2026, then convert to a year-on-year change.
- Ranges. We backtest the same method at every forecast origin from January 2015 for horizons of 1 to 12 months and take the 10th and 90th percentiles of the errors as the 80% range.
- Rate approvals. Counts and the median use every approval in FSRA's public database with an approval date from 1 July 2026, as published on 18 November 2026. FSRA's figures are averages across an insurer's renewals, not individual premium changes.
- Reproducibility. The data fetch, forecasts and charts are produced by scripts that rerun each quarter on the latest official releases.
Get a note when something in this market changes.
SubscribeHow Inaza can help
With approvals near zero and repair costs still rising, Ontario's margin comes from handling claims and renewals more efficiently. Inaza automates the routine parts:
- Automate repair estimate review against current rates. Inaza reads estimates and supplements as they arrive and flags line items above the rates you set.
- Check theft claims against recovery and document evidence before payment. Inaza pulls recovery status, ownership and finance documents together so total losses on high-risk models get the right checks.
- Record accident benefit selections at sale and renewal. Inaza checks that policy documents match the coverages chosen, so claims staff know what was bought.
To see how this would work on your own book, talk to the Inaza team.
Sources
- 1. Statistics Canada, Table 18-10-0004-01, Consumer Price Index, monthly, not seasonally adjusted, Ontario (vectors v41691997, v41691995, v41691992, v41691958, v41691959, v41691919). Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
- 2. Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario, Private passenger automobile insurance rate approvals database. Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
- 3. Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario, Changes in Statutory Accident Benefits coverage in Ontario on July 1, 2026.
- 4. Équité Association, 2025 Auto Theft Trend Report shows that despite the ongoing decline in theft rates, Canadians continue to bear $900 million in costs annually, news release, 11 Feb 2026.
- 5. Équité Association, First Half of 2026 Auto Theft Trend Report, news release, 11 Aug 2026.
- 6. Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario, Fake auto insurance website could cost consumers, announcement, 10 Nov 2026.
Subscribe to Inaza Insights
Get the monthly reports, the quarterly outlook and live alerts by email.