Skip to content
Ontario Insights · November 2026 edition

Ontario auto claim costs, October 2026: premiums flat, repair costs up

Niall CrowleyNovember 18, 2026 · 4 min read

Data period: Statistics Canada CPI for October 2026; FSRA rate approvals dated 1 July to 10 November 2026

Ontario claim costs: premiums flat, repair costs up 4.2%. Inaza Insights, Ontario. By Niall Crowley.

Ontario's auto insurance prices have stopped rising. Statistics Canada's consumer price index for passenger vehicle insurance premiums in Ontario was unchanged, 0.0%, in the year to October 2026, down from +8.3% a year earlier [1]. Repair costs did not stop. Passenger vehicle parts, maintenance and repairs in Ontario rose +4.2% (adverse for insurers) over the same year, the fastest pace in the past 13 months [1].

The Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) approvals point the same way. Of the 21 private passenger auto rate approvals FSRA has published with approval dates since 1 July 2026, eight are decreases, seven are no change and six are increases, and the median approved change is 0.0% [2]. Meanwhile the July 2026 accident benefits reforms are changing what an Ontario auto policy covers [3].

Key findings

  • Executive

    Ontario's auto premium index was unchanged, 0.0%, in the year to October 2026, while repair costs rose +4.2% (adverse for insurers). Unless frequency or injury costs fall, the gap lifts the Ontario auto loss ratio in 2027.

  • Claims

    Parts, maintenance and repairs in Ontario rose +4.2% (adverse for insurers) in the year to October, the fastest in 13 months, and vehicle purchase prices rose +2.2% (adverse for insurers), so repairable and total loss severity are both still rising.

  • Underwriting

    Of 21 FSRA private passenger approvals dated since 1 July 2026, 8 were decreases, 7 no change and 6 increases, with a median of 0.0%. Most take effect on renewals from December 2026 to March 2027.

  • Underwriting

    Since 1 July 2026, income replacement, non-earner, caregiver and several other accident benefits are optional coverages that must be offered. Clear records of what each policyholder chose will matter at claim time.

What you can do about this

For executives

  1. 1

    Plan 2027 Ontario auto results on flat prices and rising repair costs

    A 0.0% premium index against 4.2% (adverse for insurers) repair inflation means the loss ratio drifts up unless frequency falls. Lower theft helps comprehensive results but does not close the gap on its own.

For claims teams

  1. 1

    Automate repair estimate review against current labour and parts rates

    Repair costs are rising at 4.2% (adverse for insurers) a year. Flag estimates and supplements whose labour rates or parts prices run above your current benchmarks.

For underwriters

  1. 1

    Record accident benefit selections at sale and renewal

    Optional accident benefits apply as policies renew. Make sure the coverage chosen, and any written agreement to change it, is on file and visible to claims staff.

  2. 2

    Re-rate renewals segment by segment before filing flat

    The median FSRA approval since July is 0.0%. Check which territories and vehicle classes carry the most repair cost before accepting a flat average.

Prices flat, repair costs rising

Year-on-year change, Ontario CPI, Jan 2024 to Oct 2026

Source: Statistics Canada, Table 18-10-0004-01, Ontario, not seasonally adjusted, as of November 18, 2026

Ontario auto premiums have flattened while repair costs rise

Year-on-year change, Ontario CPI, Jan 2024 to Oct 2026

Source: Statistics Canada, Table 18-10-0004-01, Ontario, not seasonally adjusted, as of November 18, 2026

Ontario auto premiums have flattened while repair costs rise

Year-on-year change, Ontario CPI, Jan 2024 to Oct 2026

LabelPassenger vehicle insurance premiumsParts, maintenance and repairs
Jan 2410.64.9
Feb 2410.94.9
Mar 24124.9
Apr 2411.93.7
May 2411.73.7
Jun 2413.53.7
Jul 2412.92.3
Aug 2413.42.3
Sep 24142.3
Oct 2412.92
Nov 2412.12
Dec 24122
Jan 25123.2
Feb 2511.13.2
Mar 2510.33.2
Apr 2511.63.4
May 2512.53.4
Jun 2510.43.4
Jul 2510.64.8
Aug 259.44.8
Sep 257.84.8
Oct 258.33.9
Nov 257.13.9
Dec 255.63.9
Jan 265.53.1
Feb 267.43.1
Mar 2653.1
Apr 263.13.8
May 261.33.8
Jun 2613.8
Jul 2613.1
Aug 261.83.1
Sep 2613.1
Oct 2604.2

Source: Statistics Canada, Table 18-10-0004-01, Ontario, not seasonally adjusted, as of November 18, 2026

Ontario CPI measure

Year on year, Oct 2026

Year on year, Oct 2025

Passenger vehicle insurance premiums

0.0%

+8.3%

Passenger vehicle parts, maintenance and repairs

+4.2% (adverse for insurers)

+3.9%

Purchase of passenger vehicles

+2.2% (adverse for insurers)

+4.0%

Homeowners' home and mortgage insurance

+2.0%

+3.8%

All items

+2.5%

+1.8%

Table

Ontario CPI measure

Year on year, Oct 2026

Year on year, Oct 2025

Passenger vehicle insurance premiums

0.0%

+8.3%

Passenger vehicle parts, maintenance and repairs

+4.2% (adverse for insurers)

+3.9%

Purchase of passenger vehicles

+2.2% (adverse for insurers)

+4.0%

Homeowners' home and mortgage insurance

+2.0%

+3.8%

All items

+2.5%

+1.8%

The insurance premium index slowed steadily through 2026, from +5.5% in January to +1.0% by June and zero in October [1]. Over the same months the repair index held between 3.1% and 4.2% [1]. Vehicle purchase prices, which drive total loss settlements, were up +2.2% (adverse for insurers) [1].

For a personal auto book, the gap between a flat premium index and repair costs rising about 4% a year is margin that has to come from somewhere else: lower frequency, lower injury costs, or rate.

Want the next report when it comes out? We can email it to you.

Subscribe

FSRA approvals: more decreases than increases, but a median of zero

Private passenger auto rate approvals with approval dates from 1 July 2026, by approved average change (n=21)

Source: Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario, auto rate approvals database, retrieved 18 November 2026, as of November 18, 2026

FSRA approvals since July: decreases and increases roughly balance

Private passenger auto rate approvals with approval dates from 1 July 2026, by approved average change (n=21)

Source: Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario, auto rate approvals database, retrieved 18 November 2026, as of November 18, 2026

FSRA approvals since July: decreases and increases roughly balance

Private passenger auto rate approvals with approval dates from 1 July 2026, by approved average change (n=21)

LabelApprovals
Down more than 2%4
Down up to 2%4
No change7
Up up to 2%2
Up more than 2%4

Source: Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario, auto rate approvals database, retrieved 18 November 2026, as of November 18, 2026

FSRA's public database lists the approved average rate change for each insurer, the approval date and the renewal date it applies from [2]. Since 1 July 2026:

  • Eight approvals were decreases, the largest -4.89%, filed on behalf of a group of Ontario mutual insurers.
  • Seven approvals were no change.
  • Six were increases, the largest +8.7% for the Facility Association, the residual market for drivers who cannot find cover elsewhere, effective for renewals from 6 November 2026 [2].

FSRA notes that an approved change is the expected average across an insurer's renewals, not the change any one customer will see [2]. Many of the approvals take effect on renewals from December 2026 to March 2027, so most of the effect on earned premium falls in 2027.

Monthly reports and live alerts, by email, when you want them.

Subscribe

Accident benefits reforms from July 2026

From 1 July 2026, medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits remain mandatory in Ontario auto policies, while a range of other accident benefits, including income replacement, non-earner and caregiver benefits, became optional coverages that insurers must offer [3]. Existing policies keep their previous coverage until renewal unless the insured agrees in writing to change it [3].

The claims effect will build slowly as policies renew. Two things to watch are fewer income replacement claims on policies that drop the cover, and more disputes about what a policyholder chose, which makes clear records of coverage selection at sale and renewal important.

What it means for loss ratios

A flat premium index against repair costs rising 4.2% (adverse for insurers) a year means the Ontario auto loss ratio rises unless frequency or injury costs fall. Équité Association reports that auto theft in Ontario fell 22% in 2025 [4], which helps comprehensive results, and the accident benefits reforms may lower some injury costs over time [3]. Neither is yet large enough in public data to offset repair inflation on its own.

Get a note when something in this market changes.

Subscribe

How Inaza can help

Ontario's July reforms changed what has to be checked on every accident benefits file. Inaza automates the routine parts:

  • Automate repair estimate review against current labour and parts rates. Inaza reads estimates as they arrive and flags line items above the rates you set.
  • Record accident benefit selections at sale and renewal. Inaza checks that policy documents match the coverages chosen, so claims staff can see what was bought when a claim arrives.
  • Re-rate renewals on current repair cost data. Inaza brings policy, vehicle and claim data together at renewal so underwriters can see where flat rates leave a segment short.

To see how this would work on your own book, talk to the Inaza team.

ShareXin

Subscribe to Inaza Insights

Get the monthly reports, the quarterly outlook and live alerts by email.

Subscription type *
Regions *