Skip to content
Florida Insights · November 2026 edition

Florida auto and property claim costs, October 2026: rates are falling faster than repair costs

Niall CrowleyNovember 18, 2026 · 5 min read

Data period: BLS CPI for September 2026 (used vehicles: October 2026); OIR and DFS releases of 26 and 29 October 2026; OIR Hurricane Isaias data to 6 November 2026

Florida claim costs: rates falling faster than repair costs. Inaza Insights, Florida. By Niall Crowley.

Florida's auto rates are coming down at a pace few states have seen. The Office of Insurance Regulation (OIR) says the top five auto groups show a 2026 indicated rate change of -12.6%, covering 81% of the state's auto market, after the state's personal auto liability loss ratio fell to 52.5% (favorable for insurers) in 2025, its lowest in 15 years [1]. The cost of fixing cars has not followed. Motor vehicle maintenance and repair prices were up +5.8% (adverse for insurers) in the year to September 2026, and body work up +6.0% (adverse for insurers), while the motor vehicle insurance price index was down -5.0% [2][3][4].

That gap is the story for Florida auto in the first half of 2027. Lower rates on a book whose repair bills are still rising narrow the room that the 2023 tort reforms created. Property is following the same path: OIR and the Chief Financial Officer say more than 824,300 homeowners are receiving rate decreases on policies written or renewed in October [5].

A note on the data: the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) did not collect October 2025 prices during the federal shutdown, so October 2026 year-on-year changes are not available for most series. This piece uses September 2026, the latest month with a full year-on-year comparison, unless stated.

Key findings

  • Executive

    Florida's 2025 personal auto liability loss ratio was 52.5% (favorable for insurers), the lowest in 15 years, and the top five auto groups show a 2026 indicated rate change of -12.6%. Rates are now falling while repair costs are not, so 2027 margins narrow from both sides.

  • Claims

    Motor vehicle maintenance and repair prices rose +5.8% (adverse for insurers) and body work +6.0% (adverse for insurers) in the year to September 2026, while parts rose only +0.8%. Labour and services are driving severity.

  • Underwriting

    The motor vehicle insurance price index fell -5.0% in the year to September 2026, and more than 824,300 Florida homeowners are receiving rate decreases in October. Renewal pricing is moving against claim cost trends in both auto and property.

  • Claims

    Used vehicle prices in the South fell -3.0% (favorable for insurers) in the year to October 2026, which eases total loss severity a little and partly offsets repair inflation.

What you can do about this

For executives

  1. 1

    Plan 2027 auto results on a narrowing margin, not on the 2025 loss ratio

    A 52.5% (favorable for insurers) 2025 liability loss ratio is the starting point. With indicated rates of -12.6% and repair prices up 5.8% (adverse for insurers) a year, both sides of the ratio move against results through 2027.

For claims teams

  1. 1

    Automate repair estimate checks against current labour and parts rates

    Body work is up 6.0% (adverse for insurers) and maintenance and repair 5.8% (adverse for insurers), while parts are up only 0.8%. Flag estimates whose labour hours or rates run above your current benchmarks.

  2. 2

    Triage Isaias and flood property claims by document completeness at first notice

    About 68,000 Isaias claims were reported in five weeks. Route complete low-severity files straight to payment review so adjusters stay on the complex losses.

For underwriters

  1. 1

    Re-rate renewals segment by segment before passing on decreases

    Indicated decreases are average figures. Check which vehicle classes and territories have the highest repair share before applying a flat decrease at renewal.

Auto: the rate cycle has turned, repair inflation has not

OIR's figures show how far the cycle has moved. Florida ranked first among states for the lowest personal auto liability loss ratio in 2025, at 52.5% (favorable for insurers), and the five largest auto groups are indicating double-digit average decreases for 2026 [1]. In October alone OIR announced a further program decrease averaging -7% for one large group, affecting more than 498,000 policies, with individual averages ranging from -0.4% to -11.2% [1].

Claim costs are moving the other way. In the year to September 2026:

Measure (U.S. city average unless stated)

Year on year, Sep 2026

Year on year, Sep 2025

Motor vehicle maintenance and repair

+5.8% (adverse for insurers)

+7.7%

Motor vehicle body work

+6.0% (adverse for insurers)

+5.4%

Motor vehicle parts and equipment

+0.8%

+3.1%

Used cars and trucks, South region (October)

-3.0% (favorable for insurers)

+4.4%

Medical care, South region

+1.7%

+1.9%

Motor vehicle insurance (price index)

-5.0%

+3.1%

Table

Measure (U.S. city average unless stated)

Year on year, Sep 2026

Year on year, Sep 2025

Motor vehicle maintenance and repair

+5.8% (adverse for insurers)

+7.7%

Motor vehicle body work

+6.0% (adverse for insurers)

+5.4%

Motor vehicle parts and equipment

+0.8%

+3.1%

Used cars and trucks, South region (October)

-3.0% (favorable for insurers)

+4.4%

Medical care, South region

+1.7%

+1.9%

Motor vehicle insurance (price index)

-5.0%

+3.1%

Year-on-year change, U.S. city average, Jan 2024 to Sep 2026

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI series CUUR0000SETD and CUUR0000SETE. October and November 2025 are left out because BLS did not collect them, as of November 18, 2026

Repair prices keep rising while the insurance price index falls

Year-on-year change, U.S. city average, Jan 2024 to Sep 2026

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI series CUUR0000SETD and CUUR0000SETE. October and November 2025 are left out because BLS did not collect them, as of November 18, 2026

Repair prices keep rising while the insurance price index falls

Year-on-year change, U.S. city average, Jan 2024 to Sep 2026

LabelMotor vehicle maintenance and repairMotor vehicle insurance
Jan 246.520.6
Feb 246.720.6
Mar 248.222.2
Apr 247.622.6
May 247.220.3
Jun 24619.5
Jul 244.618.6
Aug 244.116.5
Sep 244.916.3
Oct 245.814
Nov 245.712.7
Dec 246.211.3
Jan 255.911.8
Feb 255.811.1
Mar 254.87.5
Apr 255.66.4
May 255.17
Jun 255.26.1
Jul 256.55.3
Aug 258.54.7
Sep 257.73.1
Dec 255.42.8
Jan 264.90.5
Feb 265.60.2
Mar 266.10.8
Apr 265.10.2
May 266.1-2
Jun 267-4.1
Jul 266.6-4.5
Aug 265.2-5.1
Sep 265.8-5

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI series CUUR0000SETD and CUUR0000SETE. October and November 2025 are left out because BLS did not collect them, as of November 18, 2026

Labour-heavy repair work is doing the damage. Parts inflation has cooled to +0.8%, but maintenance and repair services and body work are still rising at close to 6% [2][3][6]. Used vehicle prices in the South region fell -3.0% (favorable for insurers) in the year to October, which eases total loss severity a little [7]. Medical care prices in the South rose a modest +1.7%, which matters for personal injury protection and bodily injury severity [8].

The BLS insurance index is a consumer price, not an insurer's earned premium, and it covers the whole U.S., not Florida alone. It is still the clearest public signal that the price side is falling while the repair side is not [4].

Year-on-year change, September 2026 (used vehicles: October 2026)

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI: CUUR0000SETD01, CUUR0000SETD, CUUR0300SAM, CUUR0000SETC, CUUR0300SETA02, CUUR0000SETE, as of November 18, 2026

Labour-heavy repair costs lead claim inflation

Year-on-year change, September 2026 (used vehicles: October 2026)

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI: CUUR0000SETD01, CUUR0000SETD, CUUR0300SAM, CUUR0000SETC, CUUR0300SETA02, CUUR0000SETE, as of November 18, 2026

Labour-heavy repair costs lead claim inflation

Year-on-year change, September 2026 (used vehicles: October 2026)

LabelYear on year %
Body work6
Maintenance and repair5.8
Medical care (South)1.7
Parts and equipment0.8
Used cars (South, Oct)-3
Motor vehicle insurance-5

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI: CUUR0000SETD01, CUUR0000SETD, CUUR0300SAM, CUUR0000SETC, CUUR0300SETA02, CUUR0000SETE, as of November 18, 2026

Want the next report when it comes out? We can email it to you.

Subscribe

Property: decreases spread across the homeowners market

The homeowners market is easing too. According to OIR and the Chief Financial Officer, more than 824,300 Florida homeowners are receiving rate decreases on new policies or renewals in October 2026, with decreases of up to -12.1%. Since January 2024, 48 companies have filed for a rate decrease and 53 have filed for no change [5]. OIR says more decreases are pending for November, December and January, including about 450,000 more policyholders [5].

Those decreases are being priced into a year that still produced a landfalling hurricane. Hurricane Isaias, the only Atlantic hurricane of 2026, came ashore near Destin on 9 October [9][10]. Insurers had reported about 68,000 claims and $736 million of insured losses five weeks later, according to OIR carrier data as reported on 10 November [10]. Our separate catastrophe piece covers Isaias and the November flooding in South Florida.

What it means for loss ratios

Florida starts 2027 from a strong base: a 52.5% (favorable for insurers) personal auto liability loss ratio in 2025 [1]. But the inputs are moving against each other. If indicated rate changes of around -12.6% are earned through 2027 while repair costs keep rising at about +5.8% (adverse for insurers), the loss ratio drifts up from both sides at once. Neither figure is a Florida-only claim cost index, so this is a direction, not a forecast; our quarterly outlook puts ranges on the national repair and insurance indexes.

For property, rate decreases on top of an active hurricane and flood quarter mean less margin for adverse development on Isaias claims, and less room for error in the 2027 reinsurance renewal.

Get a note when something in this market changes.

Subscribe

How Inaza can help

The actions above can be run with your own teams and tools. Where volume makes manual checks hard, Inaza can take on the routine work:

  • Automate repair estimate checks against current labour and parts rates. Inaza reads estimates and supplements as they arrive and flags line items that run above the rates you set, so adjusters review the outliers, not every file.
  • Re-rate renewals with current claim cost data. Inaza pulls policy, vehicle and claim data together at renewal so underwriters can see where a rate decrease leaves a segment short.
  • Triage property claims by document completeness at first notice. Inaza checks photos, estimates and proof of loss on arrival and routes complete files straight to payment review.

To see how this would work on your own book, talk to the Inaza team.

Sources

  1. 1. Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, Commissioner approves -7% auto rate decrease, impacting more than 498,000 policies, news release, 26 Oct 2026.
  2. 2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U series CUUR0000SETD, motor vehicle maintenance and repair, U.S. city average, not seasonally adjusted. Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
  3. 3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U series CUUR0000SETD01, motor vehicle body work, U.S. city average, not seasonally adjusted. Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
  4. 4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U series CUUR0000SETE, motor vehicle insurance, U.S. city average, not seasonally adjusted. Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
  5. 5. Florida Department of Financial Services and Office of Insurance Regulation, Major rate decreases for homeowners effective this month, news release, 29 Oct 2026.
  6. 6. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U series CUUR0000SETC, motor vehicle parts and equipment, U.S. city average, not seasonally adjusted. Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
  7. 7. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U series CUUR0300SETA02, used cars and trucks, South region, not seasonally adjusted. Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
  8. 8. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CPI-U series CUUR0300SAM, medical care, South region, not seasonally adjusted. Retrieved 18 Nov 2026.
  9. 9. Florida Atlantic University, El Nino held the Atlantic to one hurricane in 2026, fewest since 1925, news release, 16 Nov 2026.
  10. 10. Insurance Journal, Five weeks after Isaias, 68,000 claims and $736M in losses, Florida carrier data show (Florida OIR data updated 6 Nov 2026), 10 Nov 2026.
ShareXin

Subscribe to Inaza Insights

Get the monthly reports, the quarterly outlook and live alerts by email.

Subscription type *
Regions *